Hoi4 collaboration government reddit

(which gives portugal cores on all of Spain}. I wish you a nice day. It also lowers the surrender threshold. The best way would be to copy a division template that uses Russian manpower and convert your divisions to that or train new ones. I’ve just beaten the Allies, but I don’t see a way to give them Hong Kong or France’s territory. A new page will appear in front of you. Wait til they start deploying useless 10-width pure infantry divisions and you get bombarded with notifications. Sort by: VerjenRyan. You need 80% compliance to get a collaboration government running, so a couple of operation repeats should do the trick. Had the same thing with Bulgaria, stealing Istria and Zara from Italy this way. Collab governments are great. Win the war, annex portugal, get compliance up. 9. Decided to do odd run. I’m considering doing a run as Portugal, (I may take the Empire of Portugal and Brazil path in the focus tree) and going for the “Go Ahead, Macau My Day” achievement. •. For this, switch to the Intelligence page again and click the “ Prepare ” button. I wonder if anyone knows whether collab government established before the peace conference adds favor at the conference (i. 1 example: if you can use "the prepare collaboration government" operation only 4 times before going to war and annexing 2 fictional countries A&B with the exact same industry: A & B have each in this example 20 military and 20 civilian factories and the operation would give 20% compliance each time if you mean like releasing a country as a collaboration government, the real terms benefits are: they have more access to their own manpower generally, so can make colonial divisions and give you garrison support, as well as removing the need to garrison the country. Playing as France, I don't see an option for Prepare a Collaboration May 5, 2023 · HOI4 Collaboration Government. But it is still so f*cking stupid that I can't transfer the land to my collaboration government like how I did with the normal puppets. Once it hits 80%, you can set up a collaborarion government puppet (non-democratic), which get the fun names like "French Italy" or "Japanese China" which give you loads Works fine for the Baltic States, but not for the ceded territories in Eastern Poland. You can just not Ethiopia I believe. Forming collaboration governments as non-aligned while in a democratic faction. As Kingdom of Spain declare war on Portugal that went commie and iberian union. With a collaboration government you have the bonus of gaining the majority of factories from a state (80?) But to my knowledge none of the manpower. By default, Compliance will increase daily by 0. On the TAG chosen, when the operation complete, you get 30% or 45% bonus toward compliance on their core in the case of them capitulating or being annexed by you. That’ll tell you the buffs and debuffs. Reply. When your Network in that country reaches 50%, we can say that it is time to start the “Prepare Collaboration Government” operation. Releasing collaborated land into a collaboration government seems useless? Discussion. I can't find a command for it myself. Spy Mission Collaboration Government Bugs. Hello all, I've done a couple of "Prepare Collaboration Government" missions, and they all succeeded. BUT, you need to do this 4 times, meaning it takes 5+ years IF you do not fail. government. Doing the mission gives 30% or 45% with bonus collab. But after selecting and the peace deal is done they are not a I am not talking about the espionage action of setting one up before a war. Feb 28, 2020 · The "operations" are sending spies before/under the war, using the mission setup collaboration government. Modifiers or effects, such as the following: [b] "Root out resistance" mission: Base -10%, increased by upgrading the agency or assigning more agents. It just takes a long ass time. If you do it right your collaboration government should have gotten the navy. If you set up a collab government with only Macau, the run can continue. The normal way you will most likely increase Compliance in states in HOI4 is by setting up gentle Occupation Laws. Each subsequent agent is only 50% as efficient as the previous one. But if you get enough compliance in an already conquered region, you can take a decision to set up a collaboration government. Bear in mind, you’ll need 2 spies to complete the mission. If you want to make a country capitulate easier as a democracy i suggest you do Propaganda and instigate resistance movements. also i'm pretty sure vichy gets the lion's share of the french navy which a collaboration goverment doesn't. At the peace deal, I get the following option which says create collaboration government in the tool tip. The only way to get another nation navy is to puppet them during a peace deal (and annex them). i just do a 3x collaboration government in france before attacking it. then i capitulate it and form the puppet via the collaboration government tab thus also absorbing the vichy france. Does a collaboration government get a generic focus tree that it can progress down? Question If I set up a collaboration government in a country or territory, will it get the generic focus tree (assuming it doesn't already have one) to eventually get extra factories and dockyards on its own via focuses? Oct 8, 2023 · France occupied territories have tons of debuffs that make impossible get high collab by "normal way", so its worth a collab government here. Collab Govs also make the initial Collaboration higher once they cap so that you get more factories, resources, and manpower from the beginning of occupation. The collaboration government will receive all of the Soviet cores, and will revoke the cores you have in Belarus and Ukraine. Collaboration Government . This behavior has been present in the game since before La Resistance, since releasing any country will relinquish whatever cores you had on it. Lately, every time I make use the spy mission for a "collaboration government", all it does is lower to surrender limit. So when they capitulated I got 100% Collaboration and almost no Resistance everywhere. 075, which means you will gain 0. they will also increase their own build slots. is this a Collaboration governments normally give more factories and resources than occupied territory, and occasionally spit out divisions. Click on the state you want to add compliance to to and write in the command prompt “ compliance 100 “. Spanish Spain. I made a Collaboration Government in France and then lost a lot of factories after this. I watched FeedbackGaming's tutorial but he was able to create one near the start of the game. Edit: yes I own the main victory points. The spy operation "Prepare collaboration government" works the following way. If you don't plan on doing more than one you can skip this. The only reason to have it is to spare manpower and equipments to another garrison region, and to stop your enemies from raising resistance. ago. 531 votes, 12 comments. 49 votes, 15 comments. r/hoi4. See title: I'm neutral Brazil-Portugal, followed the focus trees, but now I am trying to do Macau my Day. In most peace deals that I tried in the second game soviets even stayed alive because of the shitty peace deals mechanics. So I did the spy missions before invading with 90% collaboration, so I should get the collaboration government. Sort by: Search Comments. 3. Hey guys, just a short question. Some examples: 1. It takes far too long. Fargel_Linellar. Assuming you have 80-90 collaboration from spies, and you turn it into a collaboration state, you lose factories, and resources . Nevermind, I have just found that Democracies can't form collaboration governments. Then I got the descision to create a Collab Government and I created one I was thinking about doing order 66 on soviet union as communist Italy but for that i need as many collab government as possible so i need to start early because i don't want to share the cake with germany, but since i need to start a civil war to become communist i was wondering if my collab government obtained during fascist government would be passed to the communist one Try to trade for resources from all your puppets to avoid a rapid increase in autonomy. This made some sense with releasing a country as fully independent, but OP • 4 yr. I assume Germany got the most land and warscore, thus the soviet capitulated to them. Is there any way to see the effect (i. Rule 5: +56 civ factories from other countries trading with my collaboration governments as France + their own factories. Wait until compliance of non core states that you’ve occupied from Soviet Union reaches 80% (faster with collaboration government operations) Create Polish-Lithuanian Russia collaboration government and then justify on Soviet Union that you’ve previously liberated. Basically the collaboration government is similar to the integrated puppet here. I know a Collaboration government basically gives you 75% of the local industry, but I am unclear how resources and Nov 8, 2023 · Occupation Laws. Every Ideology besides democracies can do collab governments. Essentially, it is a unique form of puppet government. So even if you had the ability to run the operation now (which you can't without being able to run a Collaboration governments and country tags? So, with the introduction of collaboration governments in La' Resistance, you could theoretically make 2 of the same country. Since it takes so long, you easily conquer the target long before you build up the collaboration. The map can only show a limited amount of options. Set up full collab govt in China. How much Compliance do i get when I annex a Collaboration Government. If you beat them, it increases initial compliance. It seem to crash just because it has a lot to calculate. Yes if you are going on occupying the land yourself then the 1st operation is actually the most cost effective one. How do I do this? Archived post. I usually go for: I do these since they’re all relatively But usually I'd argue you should just eat the 100 compliance so you can have all the factories. It seems like Italy can't create collaboration governments via decision—one of the conditions that has to be true to make the decision is "Original…. To get a second spy, you’ll need at least 5 branch upgrades. so i was playing as italy and saw the option to create a collaboration government in libya and greece, but in my german empire game i didn’t get the…. Playing as Germany. Put your mouse over the icon in the diplomacy menu—where international relations are. Collab govt didn’t lower threshold, still had to push all the way to god forsaken part of country. Remember last patch, where you could tripple collab ussr for Instant collab Also you will get an event to form a collaboration government instantly which is a puppet state that transfers you most of its factories and manpower iirc, but you also get those just with high compliance too so it's not really necessary. Why didn't my collaboration government mission change the Soviet's surrender limit? Playing as Japan, fighting Soviets alongside the Germans. I still don’t understand the pros and cons of annexing vs puppet vs collaboration. now i also capitulate the british but it doesn't trigger the peace deal alas either british raj or canada become a major. Ah, that would do it lol. But if you have any other Chinese state with Macau when forming the collab government then you have to restart. Anyway, well before the war even starts, you should have Poland ready for a collab. 385K subscribers in the hoi4 community. Even with 100% compliance you won't get all of their manpower as it will Apr 17, 2020 · Industry based on 1. Collaboration governments are usele--. For the collaboration government effect to pop, you need the nation to capitulate to you. 075%. For small countries, even less, down to 10 days. Like, I forfeit the land that the Germans contest, they don't Countries that have the democratic ideology cant create collab govs. Propaganda lowers War Support and Stability making capitulation down to around 35% iirc and if you can cause a rebellion to occur it I put a collab government on the Soviets as Finland, but their surrender level is still the exact same as before. I'm playing as Bulgaria, and after Italy created a collaboration government in Croatia Go to hoi4 r/hoi4 • by [deleted] View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Use collaboration governments on undeveloped lands to get their factories Collaboration Government makes your target surrender sooner (normally they don't surrender until they control <20% of their VP's but a Collab Gov makes them surrender when <30 or <40% or so. You also need 50% intel network strength and at least 2 operatives. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. EG, my last game I had 100% collab with Italy and 30% with Germany as Yugoslavia. Has anyone else encountered the problem of making a collaboration government with China each time China changes to the other warlords the effects from the collaboration government goes away even if it goes back to China again, anyone know how to fix this or had this problem? Archived post. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Paradox Development Studio. You can see this before the end of the war, if you see the collab being active (a small hand being displayed and reducing their surrender limit), then it should work as My Collaboration Government in Ethiopia formed its own faction while being my puppet. During and after the war, after I annexed both, I had 0% It is available for any non-democracy. 393K subscribers in the hoi4 community. As for the espionage mission, I believe that the anarchists have it disabled as they have something similar later in their focus tree that requires them to be at war. Ways to improve on the collaboration government operation. If I have high compliance in Russia or set up collab govern, would that lower required war score for me to take during the peace conferenc) Archived post. The only threshold that change something signification is 40% compliance r5: i just got la revolution dlc and have been playing around with the prepare collab government operation as france, and it worked perfectly fine against britain, however when i repeated the operation twice against the US and capitulated them, the compliance didn't go up to what i prepared. , high compliance) of these before I declare war? I have been working in several regions and just want to check for my own sanity where I'm at. The compliance on requires owning the territory. In any Germany play-through, once a player capitulate AI France historically it is possible to create a "German France" collaboration government state that has all of Vichy Truesurvivor585. I'm trying to test a few things out about the mechanic and I'd like to be able to add collaboration to a country or compliance to a state and I was wondering if there were any console commands for that? . 2. I am trying to complete the Macau achievement but I cannot get compliance over 80% in order to get a collaboration government. Doing a Macau My Day run, and I’m trying to figure out how to give my collaboration government in Macau land in a peace deal. On this page, you will see the cost of the operation. However, what resources you can actually access Collaboration government doesn't get generated with any navy. The collaboration government you can get with espionage and the one you get with compliance are different. Thank you! Sort by: Fargel_Linellar. I pooped out collaborationist Croatia as Italy several times. I was looking for an answer for this and I could´n find any forum or something. I have 45% collaboration. vichy is good just by the virtue of it it instantly taking over all of france, deleting all the french units and encircling all the commonwealth troops defending france by default. I dont actually gain any compliance at all. Edit: Hoi4 achievement wiki Scroll down to Macau achievement for requirements In my recent game I was wondering if it is worth to create collaboration government. Were you looking in the operation menu, when not at war you have to scroll a little bit as the collab government is generally close to the end of the list. i was used to win without collab lol, i think collab France trivialize germany game too much in normal difficult, but the debuffs are really annoying, they get low compliance and higher resistance playing "normal". Award. A collaboration government will give 75% factories and full resources, but the other factories are still in your faction. Merry Xmas and Happy Holidays, fellow HOI4 players. Each of these subjects has their own default focus tree, and will Obligatory in Soviet Union, you collaborate with government. I made Vichy France, then I established a collaboration government in Free France. Age of Wonders 4Empire of SinCities: Skylines 2Crusader Kings 3Europa Universalis 4Hearts of Iron 4Hunter: The ReckoningImperator: RomeMillenniaPrison ArchitectStellarisSurviving MarsSurviving the AftermathWerewolf: the ApocalypseVampire: The MasqueradeVictoria 3. For that matter, allow majors to get more than 2 spies. 100 compliance will give ~ all factories and resources, but ~ 40% manpower. I always recruited at least 2 Soviet spies through the training centers. There are various heads of states or modifiers Can you set up a collaboration government with land you annex peacefully, such as the Soviet Union in the USA's Join the Unions decision? Question I want to play communist USA with the eventual hope I can take the Join the Unions decision and annex the Soviet Union (even though I know it's less likely for the Soviets to be near-capitulation As others said two spies are required for a collaboration government to work. Change the operation to be max 30 days and require only 1 agent. Last time that happened for me I had to wait 6 minutes. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game… Giving Collaboration Government Land. Collaboration government in Macau. You can make them into a collaboration government, so the AI can throw shitty units at you that you don't want, while also giving you the benefit of not having the addition of their factory output! Then, if you drop their autonomy down, you can annex them so that they immediately become a resisting occupied territory. Is it possible to form a Award. Because the US government can’t even collaborate with itself. If you reduce them to 0 autonomy, you can use 300 pp to annex them. I had a collab Libya in my last Italy game. 5. If you are at peace, you also gain a 10% bonus to that 0. I am looking forward to reading your opinions. I know it is my fault that I forgot to call my Chinese puppet into war. Even if those troops fight for you and Russia gains a lot of autonomy points it doesn't matter as collabs can't raise their autonomy level. [deleted] • 4 yr. May 30, 2020 · Hearts of Iron 4 Wiki. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now Go to hoi4 r/hoi4. There were never any problems with the spies being captured. WHY TF CAN'T I RETURN THE CORE TERRITORIES TO MY COLLABORATION GOVERNMENT? IT MAKES NO SENSE AT ALL. Occupation laws: -75% to +40%. What’s the point? At 80% compliance (bare minimum for collab government) you have 87% of the factories, where the puppet only Collaboration Governments from base HOI4. While playing Kingdom of Spain, I made a collaboration government with the remaining non cored Spanish states. They can. Legacy Wikis. 303 votes, 15 comments. R5: I am going for "Macau my day" and I'm having some trouble releasing the Chinese collaboration government in Macau. And they went to shit by way of game mechanics. But sometimes, you don't want the end game of 50 collaboration goverment all joining a war so you would rather manage it If you get, say, 4 extra civ factories from preparing a collab government that you wouldn’t have gotten otherwise, isn’t that better than using those 16-20 civs fo build 1 or 2 factories in that time instead? The cost increases per successful operation, I’m pretty sure. Title. Stupid German AI can't take Kazan (even with my TACs) I decided to run a collab on the Soviets to make them cap, but it didn't do anything to their surrender progress. I guess it's because they're so similar to the Reichskomissariats, but I honestly don't know. If I’m going for a longer style of war, I almost always create collab governments on the biggest of enemies (USA, USSR, etc) 2. When you get the pop-up to make a collab government, is there a way to make it later if you say no? Like at a peace deal or something? I was wondering because I want to take some land from France and then make a collab government. To reduce this, you must increase your compliance, or your collaboration. true. May 11, 2024 · Between 1000 and 10000 state population: -20%. It says the collab “reduces their surrender level by 9%”, but nothings changed at all. any help would be grateful. I get it from Germany, when they choose the "Honor the Pact" decision. I just wanted to ask, how would I go about creating the collaboration government necessary for the achievement? collaboration government. All* cores of the country in question must be at 80+ compliance. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game… However, if they end up forming a collab government in those areas you can take over as their overlord if you win a war against them Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size Having trouble using collaboration government at peace deal. Did my own justification on them. Occupied land however, has strategic uses, as you can directly invade a neighbouring enemy. It says that I need the collaboration modifier "A new regime" to establish the state while also saying that in order to have this modifier I need my collaboration to be below 80% and have two checked conditions. KomradGeorgije. The collab government must have the capital as Macau. Collab govs are the lowest level of a puppet, lower than Integrated puppets but collab can only formed with 80% Compliance (or 90% idk), in collab you get 75% Civs and Mils of said puppet which is OP especially if you collab a major nation like Soviets or France. If a spy manages to get captured/killed, reload a save since this will mess up your timing. I personally still prefer puppeting as you can always annex them after to gain factories they get from the generic focus tree Question on collab government and peace conference. 083% Compliance daily. I know they get the generic focus tree, and can make factories for themselves, but is it really worth creating the Collaboration Goverment instead of just using the 100% Collaboration which will give you all their factories and recourses because it's at 100%? Jan 17, 2024 · A Collaboration Government is a specific state achieved after a state occupies a population. It's probably because democracy is generally considered the default, desired form of government; at least in much of the western world. Devs, will you be integrating the Collab Gov mechanics into OWB? I feel there's a great deal of potential there for emergent states and resistance mechanics, especially to slow-down the expansion of majors, especially if collab governments have fewer master/overlord benefits than in vanilla. Active Wikis. I'm playing as Germany trying to reform the HRE, and Hungary formed Austria-Hungary. I would advise getting a third one that is set to quiet network, that will maintain the intel so you won't have to get it back up to 50% for the next collab government. It will make it out of the land you control that isn’t your cores Two grand campaigns against the eastern and western colonizers in the end becoming democratic and killing Hitler. • 4 yr. I'd to share a feature, or bug, that exist in the current version of the game (all DLCs enabled) as a present for y'all. But, what would the country tag for the collaboration government then be? Question about collaboration governments. I requested them off of Germany which they accepted most. Normally, France can't create collaboration governments, however, if you pursue a form of government that does allow for the creation of collaboration governments (such as the various monarchist focuses) then you can easily have dozens upon dozens of subject nations by 1939. As an occupied state, the original population will have some resistance against the occupying state. The issue I'm having is that while I can run the focus as many times as I want on the CC Clique, the actual button to inspect collaboration governments never appears. Made a 100% Intel Network spanning all of Austria-Hungary (it only encompasses Austria, Hungary, and Czechoslovakia for now) but the option to prepare a Collaboration Government isn't appearing, even when I tried to justify a war goal. * conditions apply. Personally, I think it is worth it bcuz it lowers the resistance drastically. In my HRE playthrough I attempted to form a collaboration government in commie France to make capitulation easier, but once I joined up with Britain through the "An Alliance with the Shade" national focus, the collaboration tab got replaced with an exiled Nov 25, 2021 · Hi, I want to "Prepare Collaboration Government" for Lithuania to speed up the "Form Commonwealth" after I annex Lithuania, but it doesn't show. Yes, I can confirm this works. Plus the leader if that region will use focuses to build the region better than you. When the network reaches (I think 50-60%), you can do the mission. So I was playing Italy for the first time since BBA dropped and I usually release my colonies as puppets because I hate dealing with Africa, especially East Africa since you can’t get supplies to it easily if at all. As the bonus from the compliance is mostly the same for each %, but the 1st operation is cheaper for the same gain. To prepare a collaboration government you simply need 1 spy making a spy network in a state. I can't describe how mad I am rn. I can take it for myself, but don’t see any way to give it to my CG. Annex entirety of Soviet Union that only consists of your cores. It didn't crash. if you change to any other ideology then you can. So I would like to create one right here. e. Hi. 406K subscribers in the hoi4 community. • 2 yr. The reason for this has just occurred to me: I don't get that territory from Poland. There, I start with zero compliance regardless of the pre-war Collaboration Government preparations. That entire process is useless when in half the time you can win the war with China and In the peace deal screen you can choose the puppet option, which should Playing as Turkey. You can do collab operation multiple times, it should not show if: Collaboration is already at 100% (3 or 4 operations done) You are a democracy or in a faction with democratic country (s) Can it be that since BBA it is extremely difficult to carry out the mission "collaboration government" in the Soviet Union? Before BBA, I never had any problems with it. It also makes the map neater. R:5 so i got a event asking if i wanted to make a collab goverment in the Soviet Union i said yes and the game crashed. With a puppet you can use their manpower by using their division templates. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand You can't make collaboration government with a democratic country. I really hate those events, they keep spamming me. Tip. Hey, so I just conquered the US as Brazil (I dont even know how haha) and got 100% Collaboration with my spy agency. How do you get this mission? Do you get benefits of collaboration government from a coup? true Collaboration government option never appears as Neutral country. gv sf jz xe qa oq wx mo md zj